Arch Capital Group Ltd.

Madison Investments' Large Cap Fund highlighted Arch Capital Group Ltd. in its second-quarter 2026 investor letter, noting the insurer repurchased around $800 million worth of stock, retiring nearly 2.5% of its outstanding shares during the quarter. The fund, which holds a 5.84% portfolio weight in Arch Capital, said the company reported weak growth but maintained solid margins and substantial capital return. Arch Capital shares closed at $98.53 on August 19, 2026, with a market capitalization of $33.62 billion, and gained 5.72% over the past 52 weeks. The fund believes the buyback is an excellent use of excess capital at the current valuation.

Arch Capital Group reported second quarter 2026 results on July 28, with revenue of US$4.67 billion and net income of US$1.06 billion. The stock last closed at US$100.53, which is below a narrative fair value of US$109.84, suggesting it may be about 8.5% undervalued. Analyst consensus price target stands at US$109.84, though individual estimates range from a bullish US$125.00 to a bearish US$95.00. The valuation hinges on factors including catastrophe exposure, specialty premium trends, and future earnings multiples.

Arch Insurance North America has established a US-based transactional liability team to expand its transactional risk insurance offering alongside its existing worldwide transactional risk business. The team will initially focus on representations and warranties and tax coverage products, and will be led by William Carson, who joins as senior vice-president of transactional risk. Carson previously served as head of transactional risk, North America, at Everest and will report to Chris Christon, senior vice-president of executive assurance. Arch Insurance North America is part of Arch Capital Group, a publicly listed Bermuda exempted company with approximately $26.9 billion in capital as of March 31, 2026.

Arch Capital Group has promoted Jerome Halgan to CEO of Arch Global Reinsurance Group and Michael Schmeiser to CEO of Arch Global Mortgage Group. Both executives have held senior leadership roles within the company for several years and will continue to report to Arch President Maamoun Rajeh. Halgan joined Arch Capital in 2009 and previously served as President and Chief Underwriting Officer of Arch Reinsurance Group, while Schmeiser, with the company since 2017, previously led Arch U.S. Mortgage as President and CEO. The appointments aim to reinforce Arch's underwriting culture and promote consistent execution across its global insurance and reinsurance platforms.

Arch Capital Group has a solid track record of beating earnings estimates and may do so again in its next quarterly report. The property and casualty insurer posted an average earnings surprise of 10.86% over the past two quarters. In its most recent quarter, Arch Capital reported earnings of $2.50 per share, topping the Zacks Consensus Estimate of $2.45 per share by 2.04%. The prior quarter saw an even larger beat, with actual earnings of $2.98 per share versus the expected $2.49 per share, a surprise of 19.68%. The company currently holds a Zacks Rank #3 (Hold) and a positive Earnings ESP of +9.02%, a combination that historically produces a positive earnings surprise nearly 70% of the time. Arch Capital's next earnings report is expected on July 28, 2026.

Arch Capital Group has used acquisitions as a major growth driver, expanding its insurance, reinsurance, mortgage insurance and specialty underwriting operations. In 2024, the acquisition of Allianz's U.S. MidCorp and Entertainment Insurance Businesses increased its presence in the U.S. middle-market commercial insurance segment, while the acquisition of RMIC Companies expanded its U.S. mortgage insurance operations. The company typically targets businesses that strengthen niche expertise, broaden distribution capabilities, or increase scale in attractive specialty markets, and it generally funds acquisitions through internally generated capital, operating cash flows, and retained earnings. Arch Capital's acquisition track record is generally positive, with management historically integrating acquired businesses successfully and using M&A to enter profitable specialty niches. Shares of Arch Capital have gained 1.1% in the past year against an industry decline of 1.8%, and the stock currently carries a Zacks Rank of 3, or Hold.

Arch Capital Group has promoted Jerome Halgan to CEO of Arch Global Reinsurance Group and Michael Schmeiser to CEO of Arch Global Mortgage Group, with both reporting to President Maamoun Rajeh. Halgan joined Arch in 2009 and has served as President and Chief Underwriting Officer of Arch Reinsurance Group since 2024, while Schmeiser joined in 2017 and has led Arch U.S. Mortgage since 2019. The appointments follow the recent expansion of Rajeh’s role as President, with the CEOs of Arch Insurance North America and Arch Insurance International also reporting to him. Arch Capital Group is a Bermuda-based insurer with approximately $26.9 billion in capital as of March 31, 2026.